The rollercoaster continues.
On Monday the IHSA announced they would allow athletes to participate in club activities during their spring seasons (normally, when girls volleyball runs in the fall, no outside training is allowed while in season for participants). About 24 hours later, due to cases being on the rise again, our county and three others will be going back to Phase III protocol effective Friday.
There has been a lot of chatter on social media about the decision. A lot of people are understandably upset about the changes. There are MANY opinions on the subject matter.
I am certainly no scientist. There are huge portions of the state I cannot speak on. I’m going to stay in my lane and focus on what I know from my actual experiences the last 4.5 months. The details below will not be about what I have heard or read on social media.
I simply ask you to reflect on it with your own experiences. These are not judgments: They’re observations that I think should be considered as athletic directors react to the recent decision by the state.
I’m in touch with the county and state health department on a fairly regular basis to make sure we’re up-to-date on what recommendations are. When we shifted to Phase IV and max participant numbers were increased from 10 to 50, I asked if anything had changed from a medical perspective. It was made clear that this was done for strictly economical purposes: Cases were low enough where they felt we could loosen the restrictions a bit, and this would help businesses like restaurants where 50 patrons vs. 10 can be the difference between surviving or not. But the parameters on protocol were the same: 6 feet apart, constant sanitation, limit unnecessary contact as much as possible. Effective August 15th, all indoor athletic activities were required to have participants wear masks.
Those are the recommendations. This is what I know. This is what I also know:
*I’ve watched about a dozen Facebook Live athletic events from people in my local community. Not a single one followed the health department guidelines.
*I’ve watched a large portion of people on my newsfeeds post media of them in groups of people not following the health department’s guidelines.
*I’ve had parents and players tell me about numerous situations where their other athletic activities have been in direct conflict with the above recommendations. I’ve seen it with my own eyes as I drive around town and see fields with spectators and teams closely huddled in situations where it wouldn’t be hard to simply put themselves an arm’s length apart.
*I’ve seen that other local indoor organizations have not been requiring the mask mandate that the health department has recommended post-August 15th – even after we had a small outbreak at an outdoor facility less than an hour away from us.
*I know a lot of people who have gotten it, had no symptoms, and have been physically OK. I also know some high-caliber young athletes who have been completely compromised by this – including trips to the hospital due to having difficulty breathing. I have a former player who was in the hospital 3 times and is now over two months with lingering effects.
*In one particularly interesting situation, I had someone contact me about renting the courts for their daughter’s birthday, it’d be about a group of 30. When I explained our mitigation plan, they understood why that wouldn’t work out. Then the following exchange happened:
Customer: “Honestly, I don’t blame you. There was a party in the city a couple weeks ago, everyone got it.”
Me (confused): “You saw this on the news?”
Customer: “No, it was someone I know. An older guy died, another person is in the ICU. It’s crazy.”
This person was completely serious.
Up to this point, I had thought “I really hope it doesn’t take someone losing someone close to them to start taking this seriously”. I never considered the idea that some people would truly embrace the idea that this is just the way it is, and live their lives on their own terms no matter what happened moving forward.
I’m not here to tell anyone what this virus is or isn’t. There are plenty of sources that will reinforce the idea that this is ‘just the flu’, that the death rate is incredibly low, or that this is all some political hoax. I will not judge them for having a different set of sources that they’ve been conditioned to trust.
But this is what isn’t a matter of opinion: Anyone actually being objective can see that our community, both in and out of youth sports, has completely failed in following the basic safety protocols the health departments have put in place. Cases are back on the rise, we’re already watching other states have their hospitals overwhelmed again, and if something wasn’t done, it was only a matter of time before our healthcare system was threatened as well.
For those mad at the state, I have a couple questions:
Have you followed protocols?
If so, do you feel everyone around you has followed protocols?
If not, where should your frustration be directed?
I think one thing we can all agree on is we’d like to provide our kids with as much normalcy as possible, regardless of what we feel about the virus. I’ll conclude with a line my friend said months back, and it’s always stayed in the back of my mind.
“Not following basic safety protocols is like not touching the line when running suicides. It doesn’t matter how you feel, we are all going back to the line.”